Rounds Introduces Bill to Reform NRCS and Protect Property Owners from Government Overreach
WASHINGTON – U.S. Senator Mike Rounds (R-S.D.) introduced legislation that would reform the Natural Resources Conservation Service (NRCS) within the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA). The NRCS Wetland Compliance and Appeals Reform Act would safeguard farmers, ranchers and landowners from bureaucratic overreach by the NRCS and empower them to continue to protect their land as they see fit.
“South Dakota’s farmers, ranchers and landowners know their land better than anyone else,” said Rounds. “They are conservationists by nature and want their land to be productive for future generations. They don’t need the heavy-hand of government interfering with their ability to manage the land they live and work on.
“For years, we have worked with South Dakotans who are facing arbitrary, punitive penalties by the NRCS. In South Dakota, we know that the NRCS has made unfounded wetland determinations and levied large and unfair monetary fines where the landowner has little or no recourse. The reforms I have introduced modify some of the NRCS’ compliance rules in a manner that works for landowners, gives farmers and ranchers more control over their land and removes unnecessary, often unfair, barriers and penalties.
“The NRCS was created to work with farmers and ranchers to help them improve, protect and conserve their land and natural resources. Over time, it has veered far from that core mission, morphing into an overreaching, overbearing agency that makes heavy-handed decisions about South Dakota producers’ land using questionable methods and rationale. Landowners in South Dakota, and across the country, increasingly battle the NRCS on wetland determinations. Farmers and ranchers already have to battle the wind, rain, snow and sun; they shouldn’t have to battle their government, too.”
Once considered wasteland, wetlands were often drained so farmers could plant crops. Growing concern over the loss and appreciation of the value of wetlands in the ecological system led Congress to take action to protect wetlands in the 1985 Farm Bill. However, today, because penalties from violating NRCS compliance rules can lead to the loss of USDA services and assistance for farmers, it is vitally important that the NRCS compliance rules are fair, reasonable and within congressional intent.
The NRCS Wetland Compliance and Appeals Reform Act has been endorsed by the South Dakota Farm Bureau, the American Farm Bureau Federation and the South Dakota Farmers Union.
“I thank Senator Rounds for introducing NRCS compliance reform legislation, which will ensure farmers and landowners have a fair and equitable process when it comes to making wetland determinations,” said South Dakota Farm Bureau President Scott VanderWal. “An overhaul of the NRCS appeals and determination process is long overdue and our farmers have been requesting attention to these concerns for years."
“Farmers and ranchers are committed to caring for the land they’ve been entrusted with,” said American Farm Bureau Federation President Zippy Duvall. “We understand the importance of following environmental rules, but those rules should be enforced fairly. AFBF has been outspoken in calling for changes to conservation compliance programs, and the NRCS Wetland Compliance and Appeals Reform Act is a step in the right direction. We applaud Sen. Rounds for his continued efforts to pass this legislation.”
“Permanent easement agreements mean decisions made by previous generations could impact future generations,” said South Dakota Farmers Union President Doug Sombke. “Each generation needs to be able to make decisions that make sense for their farm or ranch. I don’t expect my sons to manage the land exactly how I did or the same way my dad or grandpa did. This Act supports landowners’ rights.”
Specifically, Rounds’ legislation would:
• Prohibit NRCS from entering into permanent easement agreements, only allowing termed easements.
• Make certain compliance penalties for newly determined wetlands can only be prospective.
• Place the burden of proof on NRCS to prove a violation (i.e. not on the farmer/landowner to prove innocence).
• Prohibit NRCS from changing rationales for wetland determinations.
• Require NRCS to go through notice and comment rulemaking for conservation compliance, essentially banning the use of interim rulemaking.
• Update NRCS’ appeals process:
o Retrain National Appeals Division (NAD) judges and agency directors in how to provide a fair and balanced hearing;
o Require USDA to provide the entire record and/or decisional documentation to the farmer/landowner at the time of alleged compliance violation;
o Allow the farmer/landowner (and their counsel) to call NRCS technical staff as witnesses in the appeal;
o Accept evidence provided by the farmer/landowner as true absent substantial evidence to the contrary;
o Compensate the farmer/landowner for legal fees if they are successful in the appeal.
• Require USDA to establish State Oversight Committees (for each state) that will oversee the appeals of wetland determinations within their state.
• Require USDA to develop an appeal process for redetermination requests NOT accepted by state NRCS offices.
• Prevent NRCS from using one-time observations to satisfy the hydraulic criteria for determinations.
• Remove all references to “woody vegetation” from 7 CFR 12.2 and 12.32.
• Create a Customer Satisfaction Survey carried out by an independent survey provider.
This legislation has been cosponsored by Senators John Hoeven (R-N.D.) and Kevin Cramer (R-N.D.).
“North Dakota farmers and ranchers take care of their land better than anyone else,” said Hoeven. “This legislation is about ensuring USDA NRCS policies are farmer-friendly and respect property rights. As we get to work on the next farm bill, we will continue to prioritize efforts to reduce bureaucratic overreach and red tape for landowners.”
“In North and South Dakota, we are all too familiar with the punitive enforcement of conservation compliance and farmers and private property rights rarely come out on top,” said Cramer. “Our bill provides much-needed reforms for the Natural Resources Conservation Service wetland determinations. It creates a more thorough appeals process, prohibits bureaucrats from being retroactively punitive, and rightly places the burden of proof on the government as opposed to the landowner. I thank Senator Rounds for his leadership and look forward to working with him on these reforms.”
Click HERE for full bill text.